1- If all of the premises are true and the argument is valid, the conclusion MUST be valid
2- If all the premises
are true and the conclusion is false, the argument must be invalid.
3- If the argument is valid and the conclusion
is false, at least one premise must be false.
Valid Arguments (if...then)
1-
Affirming the antecedent
If P, then Q example: if this metal is gold,
it will NOT dissolve in nitric acid. This metal is gold.
P, therefore Q
Therefore it will NOT dissolve in nitric acid
2- Denying the Consequence
If P, then Q
example: If I can do long division, then I can add and subtract.
Not Q, therefore not P I can
not add and subtract, therefore can NOT do long division
3- Chain Argument (hypothetical syllogism)
If P, then Q example: If money is tight, interest rates rise.
If Q,
then R
If interest rates rise, loan volume decreases
Therefore if P, then R Therefore if money
is tight, loan volume decreases
Fallacies
1-
Fallacy of affirming the consequent
If P, then Q example: If I can do
long division, then I can add and subtract.
If Q, therefore P
If I can add and subtract, I can do long division
2- Fallacy of denying the antecedent
If
P, then Q example: If I locked my car, it won't be stolen
If not
P, then not Q I did not lock my car, therefore it will be stolen